Elliot’s Debates: Volume 2
Convention of Massachusetts, February 2, 1788
Saturday, February 2.The Hon. Mr. STRONG went into a particular discussion of the several amendments recommended in the proposition submitted by his excellency, each of which he considered with much attention. He anticipated the good effect it must have in conciliating the various sentiments of gentlemen on the subject, and expressed his firm belief that, if it was recommended by the Convention, it would be inserted in the Constitution.
Gen. THOMPSON said, we have no right to make amendments. It was not, he said, the business we were sent for. He was glad, he said, that gentlemen were now convinced it was not a perfect system, and that it wanted amendments. This, he said, was different from the language they had formerly held. However, as to the amendments he could not say amen to them, but they might be voted for by some menhe did not say Judases.
Mr. PARSONS, Col. ORNE, Mr. PHILLIPS, the Rev. Mr. NILES. and several other gentlemen, spoke in favor of the proposition, as a conciliatory measure, and the probability of the amendments being adopted. Mr. NASSON, Dr. TAYLOR, Mr. THOMAS, (of Middleboro’,) and others, though in sentiment with gentlemen on the propriety of their being admitted into the Constitution, did not think it was probable they would be inserted.
Before the Convention adjourned, Gen. Whitney moved that a committee, consisting of two from each county, should be raised, to consider the amendments, or any other that might be proposed, and report thereon. Hon. Mr. Sedgwick seconded the motion.
Hon. Mr. DALTON. Mr. President, I am not opposed to the motion; but, sir, that gentlemen may not again say, as has been the case this day, that the gentlemen who advocate the measure of the proposition were now convinced that amendments to the Constitution are indispensable, I, sir, in my place, say, that I am willing to accept the Constitution as it is; and I am in favor of the motion of proposing amendments, only as it is of a conciliating nature, and not as a concession that amendments are necessary.
The motion was put, and carried unanimously. The following gentlemen were then appointed on the said committee, viz.:
Hon. Mr. Bowdoin, Mr. Southworth, Mr. Parsons, Hon. Mr. HutchinsonHon. Mr. Dana, Mr. WinnHon. Mr. Strong, Mr. BodmanHon. Mr. Turner, Mr. Thomas, of PlymouthDr. Smith, Mr. BournHon. Mr. Spooner, Mr. BishopRev. Dr. Hemmenway, Mr. BarrellMr. Mayhew Hon. Mr. Taylor, Hon. Mr. SpragueMr. Fox, Mr. LongfellowMr. Sewall, Mr. SylvesterMr. Lusk, Hon. Mr. Sedgwick.