An Interview with John Moser, editor of American Foreign Policy since 1899

An Interview with John Moser, editor of our latest CDC volume, American Foreign Policy since 1899.

Why is it important for American students to understand America’s approach to foreign policy in the 20th and 21st centuries?   Why do you find it so compelling?

I’m interested in the development of republican (small-r) foreign policy. Traditionally the great powers have been monarchies of one type or another. Alexis de Tocqueville in Democracy in America predicted that Americans would struggle with foreign affairs, since they lacked hereditary royal and noble families to give consistency and continuity to the nation’s goals. Obviously that did not prevent the United States from becoming a world power. Was that because of luck, geography or something else? Is there a particular American style of foreign policy, and if so, how has it evolved since 1900?

What, if any, misconceptions or oversimplifications do you find that your students bring to understanding this theme or era? How can teachers overcome these issues?  Is there any background information that you find to be particularly helpful?

Presidential Statesmanship

Today’s students have grown up in a time when the United States was always a hegemonic power. It comes as a surprise to them that for most of the country’s history the US was a regional power at best, and that there were long periods when Americans wanted to have nothing to do with overseas commitments–what Jefferson called “entangling alliances.” The country also haven’t had a serious rival power since the collapse of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s, although it’s looking increasingly likely that the United States becoming is unwilling or unable to bear the responsibilities that global leadership demands, and if that’s the case then the world in the coming decades is going to look a lot different. I think that these documents reflect the struggle of Americans to adapt themselves to a more positive role in world affairs, and could be helpful in acclimating student to a 21st-century world in which the United States no longer has hegemony.

Tell us a bit about the process of choosing documents for this book.  Was it difficult to narrow down the document selection? Why or why not?

There are already a number of excellent volumes in the Core Documents series that touch on foreign policy, such as the excellent Cold War volume assembled by David Krugler. I didn’t want to duplicate anything. Even then there were a vast number of documents to choose from, and the size of the volume reflects that. But I tended to focus on documents associated with great debates that Americans have had over their country’s place in the world. Should we join the League of Nations? Should we provide assistance to Great Britain in World War II? Should we intervene in Vietnam? I am particularly interested in the ongoing effort to lay out a vision for U.S. foreign policy after the end of the Cold War. Containment guided the country’s strategy for nearly 50 years, but no comparable guiding concept has emerged since then.

How has the historiography on this topic changed over the past few decades?  

Since the end of the Cold War there has been a significant move toward transnational history. Earlier accounts–at least of the Cold War–have suggested a more or less passive world that followed the lead of either the United States or the Soviet Union. More recently there has been less of a focus on bipolarity, and more on the ways that other nations shaped U.S. policy. There is also more of a tendency to focus on non-state actors such as corporations and NGOs, as well as an interest in the ways that the United States has employed “soft power.”

What definitive works do you recommend to teachers who’d like to dig deeper into this topic?

I have three recommendations: George C. Herring’s From Colony to Superpower: U.S. Foreign Relations Since 1776, like all the volumes in the Oxford History of the United States series, it is an outstanding synthetic narrative. Second, Frank Ninkovich’s The Wilsonian Century: U.S. Foreign Policy Since 1900 illustrates how Woodrow Wilson’s ideas of global engagement have fundamentally shaped U.S. foreign policy ever since. Finally, Walter Russell Mead’s Special Providence: American Foreign Policy and How It Changed the World shows how not only Wilson, but Hamilton, Jefferson, and Jackson have all contributed to the American style of foreign affairs.

Do you have any “favorite child” documents?  If so, which ones and why?

I love the minutes that Chip Bohlen took of the dinner meetings of Roosevelt, Churchill, and Stalin during the Tehran Conference of 1943. They provide a succinct summary of the issues that divided the Big Three, and in a way dictated the agenda for the more-famous Yalta Conference of 1945. The minutes also record some illuminating episodes, such as Stalin’s blow-up when he thinks Soviet control of the Baltic States is being questioned, or the flippant manner in which Roosevelt responds to Stalin’s suggestion that at least 50,000 German officers be “physically liquidated” after the war. 

Download or purchase your copy of American Foreign Policy since 1899 today! 

Linked Documents

Join Our Community
of Teachers

Teaching American History provides more than just the best programs and resources available for teachers. We provide a vibrant community of practice that is there for you at every stage of your teaching career.

Ideas, resources, & opportunities to engage

Subscribe to our eNewsletter.