"Early German woodcut of a New World scene" Spencer Collection, New York Public Library Digital Collections. http://digitalcollections.nypl.org/items/510d47d9-7be9-a3d9-e040-e00a18064a99.

Documents and Debates: Chapter 1: Early Contact

ByRay Tyler
On June 9, 2020

Frequent visitors to Teaching American History.org tell us we are their go-to site for primary sources. We love hearing that. But we are never satisfied! 

We are always looking for more effective ways to package primary sources in our database to give teachers maximum flexibility in meeting students’ needs, especially the needs of reluctant or struggling readers. 

Today, we introduce a newly organized resource on the Teaching American History website with a new tool designed to engage students in controversies that animated earlier generations. Teaching American History developed the two-volume Documents and Debates Collection to illustrate the issues at stake in some of the most crucial moments in American history. Scholars from the Ashbrook Center edited each volume in the collection. Sarah Morgan Smith edited Volume 1 and Ashbrook Senior Fellow David Tucker edited Volume 2. We are supplementing this accessible collection with a new tool: audio recordings of each chapter’s primary sources. Each chapter also includes study questions and an introduction to the topic.

We begin with the first chapter of Documents and Debates, Volume 1: 1493 – 1865. Titled “Early Contact,” Chapter 1 reveals a perhaps surprising difference of opinion among Spanish writers during the first European ventures in “the New World.” 

It is difficult for 21st-century minds to comprehend the brutal treatment indigenous people received from the early Spanish explorers. The documents in this chapter ask essential questions about Christopher Columbus’ treatment of the island natives he encountered. How did Columbus justify the harsh measures he took to pacify the natives? Did others criticize his actions?  

Indeed there were Spanish critics of the “brutal and rapacious” treatment Columbus and others inflicted on the indigenous people. Theologian Francisco de Vitoria, for example, “sought to mitigate the harshness of the conquest by arguing that law—civil, natural, and divine—should prevail everywhere.” De Vitoria argued that “even in the Old Testament, where much was done by force of arms, the people of Israel never seized the land of unbelievers either because they were unbelievers or idolaters or because they were guilty of many sins against nature.” It was morally wrong to slay innocent people, “except when there are no other means of carrying on the operations of just war.” (Document D)

Columbus countered that indigenous culture in the New World was lawless and hostile to European civility. He complained that Spanish authorities had judged his actions “as they would a Governor who had gone to Sicily, or to a city… placed under regular government.” He asked instead “to be judged as a Captain who went from Spain to the Indies to conquer a numerous and warlike people, whose customs and religion are very contrary” to those of Spain (Document B). Successive expeditionary leaders acted as Columbus had, while the arguments of their critics reached Spanish royal authorities, influencing the transfer of power between governors of the Spanish settlements.

Each chapter in the Documents and Debates Collection consists of an introduction to the topic of debate, document excerpts representing competing perspectives on it, and discussion questions to help your students analyze these perspectives. Other discussion questions guide students in making connections between the debate at hand and other debates in American history. These features are available in both the paperback and PDF versions of Documents and Debates: Volume 1

What’s new? Our colleague, Teacher Program Manager Jeremy Gypton, has recorded himself reading the documents of each chapter. Teachers can follow Jeremy’s link and share the recordings with their students. This tool will be a valuable resource for teachers differentiating instruction for reluctant readers and auditory learners. 

In two weeks, June 23, we’ll introduce you to the first chapter of  Documents and Debates, Volume 2, 1865-2009: Reconstructing the South. We will post one chapter per month from each volume of the  Documents and Debates Collection until all twenty-nine debates with recordings are complete. 

As we explore these volumes in the weeks ahead, you’ll find they cover the enduring issues in American life: the effort to balance freedom and equality as well as liberty and order; the struggle for inclusion and full participation of African-Americans, women, and working people; the conflict over how America should organize its economy and what role government should have in American economic life; and the argument over how America should use its power in the world. 

Access Chapter 1 Here!


The American Revolution: Robert McDonald's New CDC Volume


Meet Our Teacher Partners: Amy Parker

Join your fellow teachers in exploring America’s history.